Newsletter
The Ball Is in Boston’s Court: White Stadium Redevelopment Gets the Green Light
November 18, 2026
Related Expertise
Emerald Necklace Conservancy involved a dispute arising from the proposed demolition of a dated athletic stadium and the construction of a new, state-of-the-art replacement stadium in Franklin Park in the City of Boston (the “City”). Plaintiffs, who were the Emerald Necklace Conservancy, Inc. and several abutters to the project site, sued to prevent the project, arguing that the land where the project would take place was parkland and subject to protection under Article 97 of the Amendments to the Massachusetts Constitution (“Article 97”). Plaintiffs also claimed that the project could not proceed pursuant to the terms of a public charitable trust, the George Robert White Fund (the “White Fund”), which had been established by the will of the Fund’s original donor, George Robert White (the “White Will”). However, the trial court, and later the SJC, held that Plaintiffs had no cognizable individual interest in the White Fund, and as such, they lacked standing to bring those claims. Accordingly, the main issue in the case at trial was whether the land underlying the project site was subject to Article 97, which requires a two-thirds vote of the Massachusetts legislature to dispose of parkland or convert it to another use.
The City originally acquired the land (the “Stadium Parcel”) through eminent domain for use as a park. However, in 1947, the Massachusetts Legislature passed a law allowing the City to convey the Stadium Parcel at fair market value to the White Fund. As an asset of the White Fund, the Stadium Parcel could only be used for purposes consistent with the will of George Robert White; one such purpose was to “create works of public utility and beauty” for Boston residents. The White Fund constructed White Stadium in accordance with this purpose. Then, in 1950, the Legislature designated White Stadium and the Stadium Parcel as a “school building and yard” and placed it in the care and custody of the Boston School Committee. Over time, White Stadium fell into disrepair. The proposed public-private partnership between the City and Boston Unity Soccer Partners LLC (“BUSP”) would create a new stadium to be shared between the City and BUSP, owner of the Boston Legacy professional women’s soccer team.
Following the announcement of this partnership, Plaintiffs sued and sought preliminary injunctive relief. Plaintiffs asked the court to (i) declare that the proposed Stadium project violated the terms of White’s Will; (ii) declare that White Stadium and Franklin Park were protected under Art. 97; and (iii) enjoin the City and BUSP from continuing the project until certain legal requirements were met. The trial court denied Plaintiffs’ preliminary request, finding that the plaintiffs failed to demonstrate a likelihood of success on the merits or irreparable harm. Later, the trial court also dismissed Plaintiffs’ trust claim, holding that they lacked standing. Following a bench trial, the trial court found in favor of the defendants on the remaining claims. Plaintiffs appealed and the Supreme Judicial Court (“SJC”) took up the case sua sponte, i.e., on its own initiative.
Regarding Plaintiffs’ claims concerning the purported violations of the White Fund, the Court held that only the Attorney General, a trustee of the trust, or individuals with a private interest in the trust have standing to bring claims concerning abuse of administration of a public charitable trust. Because Plaintiffs lacked any individual interest in the White Fund separate from the general public’s interest, they did not have standing.
Regarding the Article 97 issue, the SJC held that under the prior public use doctrine—the predecessor to Article 97—land devoted to one public use cannot be changed to a different, inconsistent public use unless the Legislature has clearly and explicitly authorized the change.
Here, the SJC held that the Legislature’s actions in 1947 and 1950 explicitly authorized a change in use of the Stadium Parcel from parkland to a school department facility, which facility was (and remains) in the care and custody of the Boston School Committee. As the SJC explained, the Legislature authorized this change in use by first allowing the City to convey the parcel to the White Fund to be used in accordance with the White Will’s broader purposes, which did not involve parks; and second, by designating White Stadium and the Stadium Parcel as a “school building and yard” and bestowing on the School Committee the responsibility for its upkeep. Accordingly, the SJC held that, as of 1950, the Stadium Parcel and White Stadium ceased being parkland. And given that the parcel was no longer parkland when art. 97 took effect in 1972, the SJC held that the Stadium Parcel and White Stadium were not subject to Article 97.
The SJC also held that a license granted by the City to BUSP for access to the Stadium Parcel over a portion of Franklin Park was not an easement, and therefore no Article 97 review was triggered by the license. As the SJC explained, the fundamental difference between a license and an easement is that a license is revocable at the will of the grantor. Given the language of the contractual agreements executed by the City and BUSP, the Court found that BUSP’s license did not create an easement to access the Stadium Parcel through portions of Franklin Park. Additionally, the SJC held that work on the roadways and pathways outside of the Stadium Parcel was not substantial enough to create a change in use of those roadways and pathways so as to implicate Article 97.
Accordingly, the Court affirmed the Superior Court decision for the defendants.
In these ways, Emerald Necklace Conservancy clarified the scope of Article 97 and the impact it may have on former parkland being developed, including impacts on surrounding and adjacent land that is not part of the development site itself.
Related People
Related Insights
Perspective
Unlocking the Future of Build-To-Rent Housing at the Annual Build-to-Rent Forum (East)
March 28, 2024






