Newsletter
Home Rule, State Rules: MBTA Communities Act Prevails
November 18, 2026
Related Expertise
Town of Marshfield v. Commonwealth involved a dispute arising from the Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority Communities Act (the “Act”). The Act requires municipalities served by the MBTA (“MBTA communities”) to have a zoning bylaw or ordinance that allows multifamily housing as of right in at least one reasonably sized district. Noncompliant communities risk losing certain state grant funding. Pursuant to revised guidelines from the Commonwealth and the Executive Office of Housing and Livable Communities (“HLC”)—the agency that sets the standards for compliance with the MBTA Act—each noncompliant MBTA community had: (i) until February 2025 to submit an interim action plan explaining how the community would comply by July 2025; and (ii) until July 2025 to confirm with HLC as to whether the community had complied.
Despite prior efforts in 2024 to come into compliance with the Act through the adoption of zoning amendments, the Town of Marshfield (the “Town”) did not do so. Following these failed zoning amendment proposals, the Town’s Select Board (the “Board”) ultimately voted against submitting an interim action plan or taking steps to comply with the Act. The HLC subsequently notified the Town of its noncompliance and stated that the Town was at risk of losing state grant funding.
In 2025, the Town and Select Board (together, “Plaintiffs”) sued the Commonwealth and the HLC seeking declaratory and injunctive relief. Plaintiffs asked the Court to find that the Town was exempt from the Act and to block its enforcement. Plaintiffs made three arguments.
First, Plaintiffs claimed that the Act is an unfunded mandate that violates G.L. c. 29, § 27C (“§ 27C”) because the Town previously spent money preparing and presenting zoning amendments at its meetings and anticipated paying more to comply with the Act and HLC’s rules.
Second, Plaintiffs claimed that the Act violated the Town meeting voters’ voting rights under the Massachusetts Declaration of Rights and violated the Town’s zoning authority under the Home Rule Amendment.
Third, Plaintiffs claimed that the Act conflicted with the Zoning Act (i.e., G.L. c. 40A, § 5) because the Act allows the Town to change its zoning laws only through Town meetings, while the MBTA Act requires the Town to have compliant zoning. Therefore, Plaintiffs argued that the Act compels the Town’s meeting voters to approve the Act.
Following Plaintiffs’ suit, the Commonwealth filed a motion to dismiss the action, which the trial court granted. Plaintiffs subsequently appealed, and the Supreme Judicial Court (“SJC”) allowed the Town’s application for direct appellate review.
Regarding Plaintiffs’ first argument, the SJC held that, as provided under § 27C, a state law constitutes a local mandate if three elements are satisfied: (1) the law took effect after 1980; (2) the law changes existing law; and (3) the law imposes a direct service or cost obligation on a municipality beyond “incidental local administration expenses.” For a service or cost obligation to be considered “mandatory,” the obligation must be one as to which the municipality has no choice but to comply and pay.
The SJC held that the Town had not made a valid unfunded local mandate claim under § 27C. Notably, the Town had not alleged facts to show that the costs of preparing and presenting zoning amendments were both involuntarily incurred and more than its local administrative expenses. The Court determined that these costs were either incidental local administration costs or costs the Town chose to incur by pursuing compliance in its own preferred way. The Court also held that the Town’s claims concerning future costs were conclusory and too speculative.
Regarding part one of Plaintiffs’ second argument—the constitutional voting rights claim—the Court held that neither the Town nor the Board had standing to make a constitutional voting rights claim on behalf of Town meeting voters. As a political subdivision of Massachusetts, the Town could not challenge the constitutionality of the Commonwealth’s own laws, aside from exceptions that were inapplicable here. The Board and its members also lacked standing because they had sued in their professional capacity and had alleged no injury personal to them.
Regarding part two of Plaintiffs’ second argument—the Home Rule Amendment claim—the Court held that while the Amendment protects a municipality’s authority over local matters, it does not stop the Legislature from passing laws on statewide issues and requiring municipalities to impose substantive requirements to implement the law locally. As the Act addresses Massachusetts’ housing shortage, a statewide problem, the Legislature had the authority to pass it under the Home Rule Amendment.
Finally, regarding Plaintiffs’ third argument, the Court held that the Act does not conflict with the Zoning Act. The Act does not take away Town meeting voters’ power to adopt or amend local zoning bylaws. It only requires that whatever zoning laws arise from the process comply with the Act.
Accordingly, the Court affirmed the trial court’s dismissal of the case.
Marshfield affirms that the Act is valid and that towns and cities must obey validly enacted statewide laws or face adverse consequences.
Related People
Related Insights
Perspective
Unlocking the Future of Build-To-Rent Housing at the Annual Build-to-Rent Forum (East)
March 28, 2024






